you're reading...
Earthbound, People

My review of the novel ‘A Suitable Boy’ (1993; Vikram Seth)

When you know that you are not an avid reader and knowing it well you choose a novel as long as 1474 pages to read, you are certainly destined for damnation.  At the end of two months (although damnation is supposedly eternal) of flowing through a roller-coaster of a story, if you end up wondering whether you had punished yourself for not reading something as wonderful as this novel for a long time, you probably know that the roller-coaster was worth all the trouble.  This is what I felt after I completed reading Vikram Seth’s coveted novel “A Suitable Boy” (1993, Phoenix House, UK).

A Suitable Boy by Vikram SethI purchased a paper-back edition of the book (1994, third impression) in a second hand book store on a gloomy day in November 2012 and I was curious how the novel so famous, could have handled Jawaharlal Nehru’s India (1950s), an India that many in my generation have wondered about but never really gotten to understand what it meant to be part of.  There is no space for ordinary people in the history books.  Historical fiction is one of the places where you can search for ordinary people and that helps you to understand history in its entirety. “A Suitable Boy” the novel helps you understand.

I didn’t know which aspects of pre/post independent India would Vikram focus on. While the novel’s sense of history and time is outstanding, for me, the thing that stands out is the spatial spread of the novel and how the characters are associated with those places.  After I began reading it, the spatial contours of the novel slowly unfolded. The book is introduced on its back cover as a love story interwoven with the story of a country in transition facing its first general elections post-independence. The story develops around a relatively young widow (in her late 40s) who is in search for a bride-groom for her second daughter (introvert, romantic-realist !).  While the love aspect is a common thread through out, the thread that really binds the story is the river Ganges (Ganga) and one should see Ganga as both Ganga and Yamuna.  The river symbolizes the very fundamental Indian ethos of pluralism.

The novel is a story of people (civilization) who are linked to one another because of a river (the non-intruding neutral observer). There is no direct dependence of the characters on the river since most of them are urbane and from a particular class in the society.  The river doesn’t figure significantly in the story although there are some moving scenes associated with it.  You don’t feel the need to be reminded.  You will know.  The imaginary town of Brahmapur (if it were to exist it would be on the banks of Ganga somewhere between Kanpur and Patna) is the only main place that is imaginary (see image below for geography of the novel).  The other prominent places in the novel viz., Calcultta (Kolkata), Cawnpore (Kanpur) and New Delhi are all on the banks of the Ganges (including its tributaries).  The only difference is that the river can flow only from the mountains to the sea whereas people can move both ways.  This is precisely what I meant when I spoke of a roller-coaster in the introductory paragraph.   The personal stories of the characters are charming in their own right and some of you might smell some melodrama in the way they go about their business.  This trait is strongly associated with Indian cinema (particularly Bollywood).   I don’t think the Indian society of 1952 was as affected by cinema as some of the more recent generations were (and are), although there is some evidence in the novel to suggest that people followed cinema even then.  The cinema industry has drawn its inspiration from societies like the one in “A Suitable Boy” and such societies have evolved by imbibing some of their own reflections by contemporary cinema.  Perhaps, one could go as far as to say that Vikram Seth’s story-telling style could have been strongly influenced by 50 years of Bollywood before him when he wrote the novel.   His handling of some of the most deeply political and sensitive matters of that time is admirable and very Indian (I can’t think of anything better). You have got to read it.

Nehru was alive and was still the prime minister of India at that time.  He even appears in the novel as himself. I had used the phrase “Jawaharlal Nehru’s India” earlier to describe what I expected from the novel when I began reading it.  Vikram Seth being 40 years too late to be part of Nehru’s India, takes full advantage of his understanding of India since Nehru and makes the novel relevant even today.   When you finish reading the novel, while the intimate human stories touch the core of your senses, you will be left wondering whether India in 1952 was ready for Nehru’s idea of India and whether we are any better today.

Kannada version of this review at ಎ ಸೂಟಬಲ್ ಬಾಯ್ at sampada.net

About CanTHeeRava

I am CanTHeeRava (ಶ್ರೀಕಣ್ಠ ದಾನಪ್ಪಯ್ಯ) from Bangalore (ಬೆಂಗಳೂರು), INDIA. Areas of my training and interests include Sciences, Indian Classical (Carnatic) Music, Languages, Poetry (Kannada and English), Test Cricket, and Educational & Political Reform

Discussion

2 thoughts on “My review of the novel ‘A Suitable Boy’ (1993; Vikram Seth)

  1. Wonderful review you have written here. I imagine Bhrampur to be around Jaipur. It’s great that you read the book as A Suitable Girl is due to be published this year.

    Posted by JoV | February 25, 2013, 10:12
    • Thanks JoV. I have heard Vikram Seth saying in a BBC radio programme (broadcast sometime last year) that the novel “A Suitable Girl” is in a prolonged gestation period. The sound of it didn’t promise a delivery in 2013. We will wait and see. I would love to co-read it with your team. Let me know.

      Just a minor point on Brahmapur’s location….it cannot be near Jaipur (which is in the state of Rajasthan in Western India). If you look at the map I have put-together, you can see Brahmapur in the eastern part of India (in the state of Uttar pradesh). The novel talks about Purva Pradesh (an imaginary eastern province). You would be surprised to know that the current large state of Uttar Pradesh is considering an administrative split into 3 states and one of them is called Purvanchal (also means Purva Pradesh).

      Posted by CanTHeeRava | February 25, 2013, 16:29

Please have your say

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email

ಹಳೆಯ ಕಡತಗಳು / Archives

Recent Posts

Blog Calendar

February 2013
M T W T F S S
« Dec   Mar »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728  
%d bloggers like this: